|Generate QR code
Open Access
Subscription Access
Economic reforms in Russia: Theoretical aspects and the practice of XIX—early XX century
https://doi.org/10.32609/0042-8736-2020-1-18-46
Abstract
This article analyzes both general issues of the theory of reforms and the history of economic reforms in Russia in the XIX—early XX century. The authors propose to consider the procces of carrying out reforms and counter-reforms as a result of interaction of several actors — “a theoretician”, “a reformer”, “a ruler”, “an elite” and “people”. During the whole Russian history reforms were of cyclic character. This article studies reforms conducted by M. M. Speransky, great reforms of Alexander II, reforms carried out by S. Yu. Vitte and P. A. Stolypin, counter-reforms of Nickolas I and Alexander III. All Russian reforms have always been aimed at the country’s modernization. However, though reforms were usually initiated for political reasons, economic reforms were in fact implemented. The tasks of modernization were realized in the first place in the military industry. Economic modernization occupied the second place by importance. Modernization of culture received much less attention, and modernization of political institutions was almost neglected. Historical experience shows that every project of modernization is unique and implies that reformers and intellectual elite are able to find those key decisions that will guarantee success. It is for this reason that the art of economic policy remains the prime factor in working out the strategy of reforms.
About the Authors
A. A. Belykh
Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
V. A. Mau
Russian Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
References
1. Ananyich B. V., Ganelin R. Sh., Paneiakh V. M. (Eds.) (2006). Power and reforms. From autocratic Russia to Soviet Russia. Moscow: Olma-Press, Exlibris. (In Russian).
2. Babst I. K. (1999). On some conditions contributing to national capital increase. In: Selected works. Moscow: Nauka, pp. 100—127. (In Russian).
3. Bezobrazov V. P. (1864). On some processes of money circulation in Russia. Moscow: Universitetskaya Tip. (In Russian).
4. Belinskii V. G. (1953). A letter to N. V. Gogol, July, 15, 1857. In: N. V. Gogol in Russian critique. Moscow: Gos. Izdat. Khudozh. Lit., pp. 243 — 252. (In Russian).
5. Bokarev Ju. P. (2014). Counterreforms: Theoretical problems. In: Economic reforms in Russia and abroad (History of world economy, Issue 3: Collected articles. Moscow: Institute of Economics, RAS, pp. 10—54. (In Russian).
6. Brokgauz F. A., Efron I. A. (1992). Encyclopedic dictionary (Reprint of edition), in 86 vols. Moscow: Terra. (In Russian).
7. Vitte S. Yu. (1896). A letter to E. A. Peretts from March, 9, 1896 with a note by S. Yu. Vitte to Nikolai II attached. In: RGIA, F. 1200, Op. 1, D. 2, L. 54—58. (In Russian).
8. Vitte S. Yu. (2006). Collected works and documentary materials, in 5 vols. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian).
9. Garvey N. (1909). A talk with the Head of Council of Ministers P. A. Stolypin. Volga. October 1. (In Russian).
10. Gerschenkron A. (2015). Economic backwardness in historical perspective. Moscow: Delo. (In Russian).
11. Goldstone J. (2015). Revolutions: A very short introduction. Moscow: Gaidar Institute Publ. (In Russian).
12. Golovachev A. A. (1872). Ten years of reforms. 1861—1871. St. Petersburg: Vestnik Evropy. (In Russian).
13. Golovachev A. A. (2016). Ten years of reforms (1861—1871). In: History of railroads in Russia. Moscow: Delo, pp. 75—101. (In Russian).
14. Dzhanshiev G. A. (1898). The epoch of great reforms, 7th ed. Moscow: Tipo-Lit. K. F. Aleksandrova. (In Russian).
15. Zaionchkovskiy P. A. (1964). The crisis of autocracy at the turn of 1870—1889. Moscow: MSU Publ. (In Russian).
16. Izgoev A. S. (2017). Born in revolutionary chaos. Moscow: Delo. (In Russian).
17. Kaminka A. (1902). Joint stock companies. A legal study. St. Petersburg: Tipo-Litografia A. E. Landau. (In Russian).
18. Kankrin E. F. (1894). Count Kankrin and his essays on political economy and finance: In 3 parts. St. Petersburg: Tip. Imperatorskoy Akademii Nauk. (In Russian).
19. Karamzin N. M. (1991). A note on ancient and new Russia in its political and civil aspects. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian).
20. Kokovtsov V. N. (1992). From my past: Memoirs. 1903—1919: in 2 vol. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian).
21. Korelin A. P. (ed.) (1994). Russian autocrats. 1801—1917. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. (In Russian).
22. Korelin A. P. (ed.) (1995). Russian reformers (XIX—early XX). Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye Otnosheniya. (In Russian).
23. Korf M. A. (1861). The life of count Speransky. St. Petersburg: Imperatorskaya Publichnaya Biblioteka. (In Russian).
24. Levin A. A. (2010). Joint stock banks in Russia. Moscow: Delo. (In Russian).
25. Leskov N. S. (1981). Stories and novels. Moscow: Khudozhestvennaya Literatura. (In Russian).
26. Mill J. S. (1980). Principles of political economy. Moscow: Progress. (In Russian).
27. Nikitenko A. V. (1955). Diary in 3 vols. Moscow, Leningrad: Goslitizdat. (In Russian).
28. Okun S. B., Sivkov K. V. (eds.) (1963). Peasants movement in Russia in 1857—May 1861: Collected documents. Moscow: Izd. Sots.-Ekon. Literatury. (In Russian).
29. Ostrovskii A.N. (1974). Every man has a fool in his sleeve. In: Collected works in 12 vols. Moscow: Iskusstvo. (In Russian).
30. Pantin V. I., Lapkin V. V. (2006). Philosophy of historical prognosis: Rhythmes of history and perspectives of world development in the first half of the XXI century. Dubna: Feniks+ (In Russian).
31. Peretts E. A. (2018). Diary (1880—1883). Moscow: Delo (In Russian).
32. PSZ II (1830—1885). Complete collection of laws of Russian Empire: 2-nd collection: [12.12.1825—28.02.1881]. St. Petersburg: Tip. 2nd Otdeleniya Sobstv. E. I. V. Kantselyarii. (In Russian).
33. Polovtsov A. A. (1966). A diary of state secretary A. A. Polovtsov. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian).
34. Polterovich V. M. (2007). Elements of the theory of reforms. Moscow: Ekonomika. (In Russian).
35. Polterovich V. M. (2008). Modern state of the theory of reforms. Ekonomicheskaya Nauka Sovremennoi Rossii, No. 1 (40), pр. 7—34. (In Russian).
36. Reitern M. Kh. (2020). On improvement of Russia’s financial and economic situation. Moscow: Delo (In Russian).
37. Rosarchive (2008). Special journals of Council of Ministers of the Russian Empire. 1909—1917: 1916. Moscow: Rosspen. (In Russian).
38. Soloviev Ya. A. (1881). Notes by senator Ya. A. Soloviev on peasants situation, Russkaya starina, No. 2, pр. 214—246. (In Russian).
39. Speransky M. M. (2015). On basic laws of a state. Moscow: EKSMO. (In Russian).
40. Starodubrovskaya I. V., Mau V. A. (2001). Great revolutions: From Cromwell to Putin. Moscow: Vagrius. (In Russian).
41. Tiutchev F. I. (1988). Poems. Letters. Memoirs by contemporaries. Moscow: Pravda. (In Russian).
42. Shepelev L. E. (1981). Tzarism and bourgeoisie in second half of XIX century. Leningrad: Nauka. (In Russian).
43. Shepelev L. E. (ed.) (2007). Fates of Russia. Problems of the country’s economic development in XIX — early XX centuries: Documents and memoirs of statesmen. St. Petersburg: Liki Rossii. (In Russian).
44. Engels F. (1962). Afterword to the paper “On social relations in Russia”. In: Marx K., Engels F. Works, 2nd ed., Vol. 22. Moscow: Politizdat, pp. 438—453 (In Russian).
45. Ascher A. (2001). P. A. Stolypin: The search of stability in late imperial Russia. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
46. Brinton C. (1938). The anatomy of revolution. New York: W.W. Norton.
47. Maddison A. (1995). Monitoring the world economy 1820—1992. OECD Development Center Studies.
48. Raeff M. (1969). Michael Speransky: Stateman of imperial Russia 1772—1839. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.
49. World Bank (2003). World development report. Washington, DC.
Review
For citations:
Belykh A.A., Mau V.A. Economic reforms in Russia: Theoretical aspects and the practice of XIX—early XX century. Voprosy Ekonomiki. 2020;(1):18-46. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.32609/0042-8736-2020-1-18-46
Views:
7695
Email this article 
