voprecotestВопросы экономикиVoprosy Ekonomiki0042-8736Voprosy Ekonomiki, NP10.32609/0042-8736-2011-9-66-79voprecotest-1149Research ArticleНАЦИОНАЛЬНЫЕ ОБРАЗЫ НАУКИNATIONAL IMAGES OF SCIENCEИнновации в экономической науке: французский вклад за последние 70 летInnovations in Economic Science: French Contribution for the Last 70 YearsПосельИ.PeaucelleI.

старший научный сотрудник Национального центра научных исследований, ассоциированный сотрудник Парижской школы экономики

Национального центра научных исследований; Парижская школа экономикиФранцияNational Center for Scientific Research (CNRS); Paris School of EconomicsFrance201120092011096679Copyright © Voprosy Ekonomiki, NP, 20112011Voprosy Ekonomiki, NPVoprosy Ekonomiki, NPhttps://www.vopreco.ru/jour/about/submissions#copyrightNoticehttps://www.vopreco.ru/jour/article/view/1149

В статье выделены разделы современной экономической мысли, новаторами в которых стали французские исследователи. Французскую науку отличают ее картезианские корни и национальное счетоводство, традиции которого наследованы от Кенэ. На протяжении последних 70 лет четко просматриваются два параллельных пути эволюции этих фундаментальных отличительных черт. Один путь складывается под воздействием исторических, юридических и психологических исследований. Его представляют: индикативное планирование, экспериментирование в экономике и теории справедливости и регуляции. Другой путь определяется включением математики. Французский вклад здесь прослеживается в таких разделах, как макроэконометрическое моделирование, теория неравновесия и количественные финансы.

In the article some branches of modern economic thought are considered, in which the French researchers have made pioneering contributions. French science is characterized by its Cartesian roots as well as by the ideas of national accounting dating back to Quesnay. Over the past 70 years two parallel paths of these fundamental distinguishing features are clearly visible. One way is formed under the influence of historical, legal and psychological research. It is presented by indicative planning, experimentation in the economy, and theories of justice and regulation. The other way is determined by the inclusion of mathematics, where the French contribution can be seen in such approaches as macroeconometric modeling, the theory of disequilibrium and quantitative finance.

история французской экономической мыслипланированиесправедливостьтеория регуляцииэкспериментальная экономиканеравновесиеколичественные финансымакроэконометрикаhistory of French economic thoughtplanningjusticetheory of regulationexperimental economicsdisequilibriumquantitative financemacroeconometricsReferencesAghion Ph. Equilibre de marchе, concurrence et formation des prix // Thèse de Doctoratde 3e cycle, Univ. Paris 1, 1983.Aghion Ph. Equilibre de marchе, concurrence et formation des prix // Thèse de Doctoratde 3e cycle, Univ. Paris 1, 1983.Aghion Ph. On the Generic Inefficiency of Differentiable MarketGames // Journal of Economic Theory. 1985. Vol. 37, No 1. P. 126-146.Aghion Ph. On the Generic Inefficiency of Differentiable MarketGames // Journal of Economic Theory. 1985. Vol. 37, No 1. P. 126-146.Aghion Ph., HowittP. Endogenous Growth Theory. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998.Aghion Ph., HowittP. Endogenous Growth Theory. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1998.Aglietta M. Rеgulation et crises du capitalisme. P.: Calmann-Lеvy, 1976.Aglietta M. Rеgulation et crises du capitalisme. P.: Calmann-Lеvy, 1976.Ait-Sahalia Y., Jacob J. Volatility Estimators for Discretely Sampled Levy Processes // Annals of Statistics. 2007 . Vol. 35, No 1. P. 355-392.Ait-Sahalia Y., Jacob J. Volatility Estimators for Discretely Sampled Levy Processes // Annals of Statistics. 2007 . Vol. 35, No 1. P. 355-392.Amable B. Demmou L., Ledezma I. Product Market Regulation, Innovation and Distance to Frontier // Industrial and Corporate Change. 2010. Vol. 19, No 1. P. 117-159.Amable B. Demmou L., Ledezma I. Product Market Regulation, Innovation and Distance to Frontier // Industrial and Corporate Change. 2010. Vol. 19, No 1. P. 117-159.Banerjee A., Duflo E. Giving Credit Where It Is Due // Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2010. Vol. 24, No 3. P.61-80.Banerjee A., Duflo E. Giving Credit Where It Is Due // Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2010. Vol. 24, No 3. P.61-80.Banerjee A., Duflo E. L'approche expеrimental en еconomie du dеveloppement // Revue d'еconomie politique. 2009. Vol. 119, No 5. P. 691-726.Banerjee A., Duflo E. L'approche expеrimental en еconomie du dеveloppement // Revue d'еconomie politique. 2009. Vol. 119, No 5. P. 691-726.Bertrant M., Karlan D., Mullainathan S., Shafir E., Zinman J. What's Advertising Content Worth? Evidence from a Consumer Credit Marketing Field Experiment // Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2010. Vol. 125, No 1. P. 263-305.Bertrant M., Karlan D., Mullainathan S., Shafir E., Zinman J. What's Advertising Content Worth? Evidence from a Consumer Credit Marketing Field Experiment // Quarterly Journal of Economics. 2010. Vol. 125, No 1. P. 263-305.Blanchard O., Watson M. Bubbles, Rational Expectations and Financial Markets // Crises in the Economic and Financial Structure / P. Wachtel (ed.). Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 1982. P. 295-316.Blanchard O., Watson M. Bubbles, Rational Expectations and Financial Markets // Crises in the Economic and Financial Structure / P. Wachtel (ed.). Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, 1982. P. 295-316.Bеnard J. Production et dеpenses intеrieures de la France en 1970. Rеsultats et mеthodes // Europe's Future in Figures / R. C. Geary (ed.). Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1962.Bеnard J. Production et dеpenses intеrieures de la France en 1970. Rеsultats et mеthodes // Europe's Future in Figures / R. C. Geary (ed.). Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1962.Bеnassy J.-P. Regulation of the Wage-Profits Conflict and the Unemployment-Inflation Dilemma in a «Keyneso-Marxian» Dynamic Disequilibrium Model // CEPREMAP. 1975. No 7504.Bеnassy J.-P. Regulation of the Wage-Profits Conflict and the Unemployment-Inflation Dilemma in a «Keyneso-Marxian» Dynamic Disequilibrium Model // CEPREMAP. 1975. No 7504.Debreu G. A Social Equilibrium Existence Theorem // Proceedings of National Academyof sciences. 1952. Vol. 38, No 10. P. 886-893.Debreu G. A Social Equilibrium Existence Theorem // Proceedings of National Academyof sciences. 1952. Vol. 38, No 10. P. 886-893.Deleau M., Le Van C., Malgrange P. The Long Run of Macroeconometric Models // Essays in Honor of Edmond Malinvaud. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1990.Deleau M., Le Van C., Malgrange P. The Long Run of Macroeconometric Models // Essays in Honor of Edmond Malinvaud. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1990.Deleau M., Malgrange P. Recent Trends in French Planning // Frontiers of Quantitative Economics. Vol. III, No 2 / M. Intrilligator (ed.). Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1977. P. 429-455.Deleau M., Malgrange P. Recent Trends in French Planning // Frontiers of Quantitative Economics. Vol. III, No 2 / M. Intrilligator (ed.). Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1977. P. 429-455.Duflo E. Pauvretе et dеveloppement dans le monde. Leçon inaugurale Collège de France, 8 janvier 2009.Duflo E. Pauvretе et dеveloppement dans le monde. Leçon inaugurale Collège de France, 8 janvier 2009.European Cities Entrepreneurship Ranking. Classement ECER / ALTIDIEM. 2009. http://www.ecer.frEuropean Cities Entrepreneurship Ranking. Classement ECER / ALTIDIEM. 2009. http://www.ecer.frGabaix X. The Granular Origins of Aggregate Fluctuations // Econometrica. 2011. Vol. 79, No 3. P. 733-772.Gabaix X. The Granular Origins of Aggregate Fluctuations // Econometrica. 2011. Vol. 79, No 3. P. 733-772.Gagliardini P., Gourieroux C. Migration Correlation: Definition and Efficient Estimation// Journal of Banking & Finance. 2005. Vol. 29, No 4. P. 865-894.Gagliardini P., Gourieroux C. Migration Correlation: Definition and Efficient Estimation// Journal of Banking & Finance. 2005. Vol. 29, No 4. P. 865-894.Gagliardini P., Gouriеroux C., Monfort A. Microinformation, Nonlinear Filtering and Granularity // Swiss Finance Institute Research Paper Series. 2009. No 10-23.Gagliardini P., Gouriеroux C., Monfort A. Microinformation, Nonlinear Filtering and Granularity // Swiss Finance Institute Research Paper Series. 2009. No 10-23.Gourieroux C., Laffont J. J., Monfort A. Rational Expectations in Dynamic Linear Models: The Analysis of the Solutions // Econometrica. 1982. Vol. 50, No 2. P. 409-425.Gourieroux C., Laffont J. J., Monfort A. Rational Expectations in Dynamic Linear Models: The Analysis of the Solutions // Econometrica. 1982. Vol. 50, No 2. P. 409-425.Gourieroux C., Monfort A., Trognon A. Pseudo Maximum Likelihood Methods: Applicationto Poisson Model // Econometrica. 1984. Vol. 52, No 3. P. 701-720.Gourieroux C., Monfort A., Trognon A. Pseudo Maximum Likelihood Methods: Applicationto Poisson Model // Econometrica. 1984. Vol. 52, No 3. P. 701-720.Gourieroux Ch., Monfort A. Econometric Specifications of Stochastic Discount Factor Models // Journal of Econometrics. 2007. Vol. 136, No 2. P. 509-530.Gourieroux Ch., Monfort A. Econometric Specifications of Stochastic Discount Factor Models // Journal of Econometrics. 2007. Vol. 136, No 2. P. 509-530.Gourieroux Ch., Monfort A., Laffont J.-J. Coherency Conditions in Simultaneous Linear Equation Model with Endogenous Switching Regimes // Econometrica. 1980. Vol. 48, No 3.Gourieroux Ch., Monfort A., Laffont J.-J. Coherency Conditions in Simultaneous Linear Equation Model with Endogenous Switching Regimes // Econometrica. 1980. Vol. 48, No 3.Grandmont J-.M. Temporary General Equilibrium Theory // Econometrica. 1977. Vol. 45, No 3. P. 535-572.Grandmont J-.M. Temporary General Equilibrium Theory // Econometrica. 1977. Vol. 45, No 3. P. 535-572.Grandmont J.-M., Younes Y. On the Efficiency of a Monetary Equilibrium // Review of Economic Studies. 1973. Vol. 40, No 2. P.149-165.Grandmont J.-M., Younes Y. On the Efficiency of a Monetary Equilibrium // Review of Economic Studies. 1973. Vol. 40, No 2. P.149-165.Juillard M. Dynar: A Program for the Resolution and Simulation of Dynamic Models with Forward Variables Through the Use of a Relaxation Algorithm // CEPREMAP. 1996. No 9602.Juillard M. Dynar: A Program for the Resolution and Simulation of Dynamic Models with Forward Variables Through the Use of a Relaxation Algorithm // CEPREMAP. 1996. No 9602.Kolm S.-Ch. Justice et еquitе // CEPREMAP, 1972.Kolm S.-Ch. Justice et еquitе // CEPREMAP, 1972.Kolm S.-Ch. Macrojustice: The Political Economy of Fairness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.Kolm S.-Ch. Macrojustice: The Political Economy of Fairness. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2005.Kolm S.-Ch. Modern Theories of Justice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996.Kolm S.-Ch. Modern Theories of Justice. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1996.Le travail: marchе, règles et conventions / R. Salais, L. Thevenot (еds.). P.: Economica, 1986.Le travail: marchе, règles et conventions / R. Salais, L. Thevenot (еds.). P.: Economica, 1986.Les bienfaits de la macroеconomie. Confеrence du Centre Cournot sous la prеsidence de Robert Solow et de Jean-Louis Beffa, Paris, 2-3 dеcembre 2010.Les bienfaits de la macroеconomie. Confеrence du Centre Cournot sous la prеsidence de Robert Solow et de Jean-Louis Beffa, Paris, 2-3 dеcembre 2010.Lipietz A. Le capital et son espace. P.: Maspero, 1977.Lipietz A. Le capital et son espace. P.: Maspero, 1977.Lordon F. Formaliser la dynamique et les crises rеgulationnistes // Thеorie de rеgulation, l'еtat des savoirs / R. Boyer, Y. Saillard (eds.). P.: La Dеcouverte, 2002. P. 264-272.Lordon F. Formaliser la dynamique et les crises rеgulationnistes // Thеorie de rеgulation, l'еtat des savoirs / R. Boyer, Y. Saillard (eds.). P.: La Dеcouverte, 2002. P. 264-272.L'еconomie des conventions / A. Orlеan (еd.). P.: PUF, 1994.L'еconomie des conventions / A. Orlеan (еd.). P.: PUF, 1994.Malinvaud E. Pourquoi les еconomistes ne font pas de dеcouvertes ? // Revue dеconomie politique. 1996. No 6. P. 929-942.Malinvaud E. Pourquoi les еconomistes ne font pas de dеcouvertes ? // Revue dеconomie politique. 1996. No 6. P. 929-942.Malinvaud Е. Decentralized Procedures for Planning// Activity Analysis in the Theory of Growth and Planning / E. Malinvaud, M. O. L. Bacharach (eds.). L.: Macmillan, 1967.Malinvaud Е. Decentralized Procedures for Planning// Activity Analysis in the Theory of Growth and Planning / E. Malinvaud, M. O. L. Bacharach (eds.). L.: Macmillan, 1967.Mandelbrot B. Fractals and Scaling in Finance: Discontinuity, Concentration, Risk. N. Y.: Springer, 1997.Mandelbrot B. Fractals and Scaling in Finance: Discontinuity, Concentration, Risk. N. Y.: Springer, 1997.Massе P. The French Plan and Economic Theory // Econometrica. 1965. Vol. 33, No 2. P. 265-276.Massе P. The French Plan and Economic Theory // Econometrica. 1965. Vol. 33, No 2. P. 265-276.Musgrave R. The Theory of Public Finance. N. Y.: McGraw-Hill, 1959.Musgrave R. The Theory of Public Finance. N. Y.: McGraw-Hill, 1959.OECD. Rеforme de la gouvernance mеtropolitaine. Paris, 2000.OECD. Rеforme de la gouvernance mеtropolitaine. Paris, 2000.Orlеan A. The Self-Referential Hypothesis in Finance // The Stability of Finance in Europa / J.-P. Touffut (еd.). P.: Albin Michel, 2006.Orlеan A. The Self-Referential Hypothesis in Finance // The Stability of Finance in Europa / J.-P. Touffut (еd.). P.: Albin Michel, 2006.Peaucelle I., Petit P., Saillard Y. AGORA: Analyse dynamique des relations entre productions marchandes et productions non marchandes // Rapport final de convention de recherche pour le Commissariat Gеnеral du Plan, 1978.Peaucelle I., Petit P., Saillard Y. AGORA: Analyse dynamique des relations entre productions marchandes et productions non marchandes // Rapport final de convention de recherche pour le Commissariat Gеnеral du Plan, 1978.Seibel С. Planification en France // WP INSEE. 1973.Seibel С. Planification en France // WP INSEE. 1973.Sen A. Choice, Welfare and Measurement. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1982.Sen A. Choice, Welfare and Measurement. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1982.Tinbergen J. Central Planning. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964.Tinbergen J. Central Planning. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1964.Tinbergen J. Economic Policy: Principles and Design. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1956.Tinbergen J. Economic Policy: Principles and Design. Amsterdam: North-Holland, 1956.Younes Y. On Equilibria with Rationing // Advances in Economic Theory / W. Hildenbrand (ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983.Younes Y. On Equilibria with Rationing // Advances in Economic Theory / W. Hildenbrand (ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1983.

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest present.